Call 020 7692 5675 Mon-Fri 8am-7pm

For immediate support email [email protected] 24/7

What should keep charity trustees up at night? 

During Trustees’ Week, Alder’s Managing Director, Tim Toulmin, joined a panel at the Eastside People Festival of Trusteeship to discuss what trustees should really worry about. The panel looked at the risks that can catch charity boards off guard. This article sets out Tim’s main points. 

Do crises really come out of nowhere? 

Rarely. Trustees are responsible for managing reputational risk, yet many boards can find themselves unprepared when a crisis hits. 

When boards look back afterwards, they often discover the warning signs were there all along. Someone in the organisation usually knew something. The information just never reached the board in a way that prompted action. 

What kind of issues can be identified before a reputational crisis hits?  

 Tim gave four examples (though there are many more): 

  • A charismatic chief executive who impresses the board but intimidates staff. 
  • Early signs of financial pressure that are explained away as temporary. 
  • Growing frustration among employees, volunteers or beneficiaries that does not show up in board papers. 
  • New risks, such as AI-enabled fraud, deepfakes or online impersonation, that were not on anyone’s radar a year or two ago. 

The common thread is timing. Problems tend to grow when nobody recognises their significance early enough. 

What is the distance trap, and why does it matter for boards? 

Alder’s recent research identified a pattern we call the distance trap. The further someone is from responsibility for crisis preparedness, the more confident they tend to be in the organisation’s ability to respond. 

This is particularly relevant for boards. Trustees have a central role in overseeing risk, but by design they sit further from the day-to-day realities of the organisation than anyone else in the leadership structure. That distance can leave a board more confident than the evidence supports. 

What can trustees do differently? 

Tim suggested three steps: 

Ask how you would know. If a serious problem was developing somewhere in this organisation, how would the board find out? If the answer is unclear, that can be a useful place to start. 

Get information from more than one source. Board papers are important, and so are complaints data, beneficiary feedback and external intelligence. If all of a board’s information comes through a single route, the board is relying on that route never failing. 

Look at legal, operational and reputational risk together. Each is a distinct risk, and each forms part of a bigger picture. Decisions that reduce one can sometimes increase another, and boards need to understand those trade-offs. Training and round table sessions can help. 

What should trustees raise at their next board meeting? 

The panel was asked for one thing trustees should do differently at their next board meeting. Tim’s answer was to ask what their role would be in a crisis. When a crisis does happen, a lot of time can be lost while people work out what they are meant to do. It is far easier to agree that before a crisis than in the middle of one. 

What does good governance look like? 

Good governance does not require trustees to know everything. It means making sure bad news reaches the board while there is still time to act on it.  

How can Alder help? 

Alder advises charities on how to prepare for, respond to and recover from reputational crises. To discuss your challenges, call or email Alder on 0207 692 5675 / [email protected]  

You might like